The best file manager


*UPDATED – July 8 2015*

Hello! Today I am going to talk about file managers/commanders.

First of all, get clear about what file manager is. It is a pretty nice solution to get rid of the dull and obsolete default Explorer in Windows. One of the first of them (and most popular) was the Norton Commander (yes, the antivirus one!) that came in the 90’s. Today all of the file managers are known as NC clones (NC – Norton Commander).

This software is something most tech geeks have played with in their lifetime, and some other non-geeks too have given it a thumbs up. But whenever someone is asked to reward one out of those hundreds of file managers as the best, everyone has varied opinion. Of course I will have too.

file manager competition
Welcome to the highly debatable topic of the best file manager on earth. (You may also know it as file commander.) So today, after months of testing the latest version of each file manager software out there, I have come up with the best of the lot. Here are those (not in ranking order):

  • Q-Dir 6.11 (FREE) (WINDOWS)
  • MultiCommander 5.11 (FREE) (WINDOWS)
  • Double Commander 0.6.3 beta (FREE & OPEN SOURCE) (WINDOWS, MAC, LINUX)
  • SpeedCommander 15.6 (PAID) (WINDOWS)
  • Directory Opus 11 (PAID) (WINDOWS)
  • Unreal Commander 2.02 (FREE) (WINDOWS)

Some would say this review is somewhat common to others. So, what was my basis of coming up with this result and not something else?

  • Practically useful features
  • Plugins support
  • Integration into Windows (replacing the Explorer)
  • Archive support (without external EXE usage)
  • Tabbed browsing
  • RAM and processor friendly / Resource friendly
  • Linux support

Why I just said Linux is because Microsoft’s future is bleak, as said here: (https://hctechbyte.wordpress.com/2014/07/19/microsoft-self-destruct-countdown-begins/
http://hctechbyte.blogspot.in/2014/07/microsoft-self-destruct-countdown-begins.html)

So, what do I expect in the chosen ones? Not all of them in any one. Surprising? Most software reviewers try to bring and claim something that has all of it. Some of them have succeeded, though later told by users that their review was a fake. Well, I don’t do all that kind of crap. I bring true results to people.

 

Q-Dir

 

Screenshots: http://www.softwareok.com/?seite=Freeware/Q-Dir/Screenshots

  • Can have upto four panes in any arrangement possible
  • Tabbed browsing
  • Can save state. For example, you are working with three folders, and you want to close the program and want to work with those very folders the next time you open the program. Use the Save State option and open the 2 KB file wherever you have saved it. It will feel as if you never closed the program.
  • Resource friendly
  • Extremely small size (>1 MB)
  • 32-bit and 64-bit support with Unicode character support
  • Portable versions available

So, it is for sure a complete file manager, right? No. Such a small package can’t have everything in its arsenal. There’s got to be some disadvantages. So here they are:

  • A bad program author who does not take time and fix many bugs altogether
  • Once integrated into Windows, Control Panel will stop opening
  • No archive support other than ZIP
  • No complex search feature available
  • No Linux support

Note: If you get habitual to Q-Dir, others will become useless for you. You can use third-party apps along with Q-Dir to make work easier. But this is what tabs are made for. Use multiple tabs for many folders in two pane managers.

 

MultiCommander

 

Screenshots: http://multicommander.com/screenshots

  • Practically completely useful
  • All plugins come with the setup, that too already configured for you
  • Good integration into Windows
  • Resource friendly
  • Superb archive support (latest RAR5 (WinRAR 5.xx) extraction supported)
  • Complex search feature
  • Small size (16 MB after installing)
  • Portable versions available
  • A very good program author who leaves no errors to complain about

So, it looks more complete. In fact, the ultimate package, right? No. Though it has two things to worry about:

  • All help is online, no help file made
  • When will the author get a Linux version out?

 

Double Commander



Screenshots: http://doublecmd.sourceforge.net/static_gallery_mirror/

  • Better than Total Commander
  • Support for every Total Commander plugin available
  • Tabbed browsing
  • Resource friendly
  • Complex search feature
  • Covers most archives’ extraction (RAR5 supported!)
  • Small size (11 MB after installing)
  • Portable versions available
  • Linux and Mac support
  • Good program author
  • Open source code (development can never stop)

It looks pretty much complete. And indeed it is. But it also has its share of worries:

  • No OS integration
  • No theme support, only single color changing for bars

But atleast if Windows goes down some day, this program will be there for Linux or Mac.

 

SpeedCommander



Screenshots: http://www.speedproject.de/sc/screenshots/

  • Simple and clean interface with pleasant themes inbuilt
  • Tabbed browsing
  • Best archive support to exist (Compression and extraction: 7Z, ACE, ARJ, BZIP, CAB, GZIP, JAR, LZH, RAR, SQX, TAR, UUE, ZIP | Extraction only: ZIPX, RAR5)
  • Quick access to the desktop and system folders (VERY IMPORTANT FOR POWER USERS)
  • Nero-like burning tool inbuilt
  • ISO making tool inbuilt
  • Complex search feature
  • Good program author(s)
  • Portable version available (http://portableappz.blogspot.in)

It has a lot of problems in it:

  • Paid (you will have to get bucks out of your pocket!)
  • Only 7-8 plugins available, that too by the author
  • No OS integration
  • German help only, no English or other language help made available till date
  • Uses moderate resources, slightly heavy for slow PCs
  • 60 MB after installing
  • No Linux support

 

Unreal Commander

 

Screenshots: https://x-diesel.com/ (slideshow on the top right side)

  • Tabbed browsing
  • Resource friendly
  • All Total Commander plugins supported
  • Complex search feature
  • Good program author
  • Small size (about 20 MB) after installing

But there are lots of problems. Here they are:

  • Bad interface
  • Portable version not available
  • No OS integration
  • No Linux support

 

Directory Opus

Screenshots: http://www.gpsoft.com.au/program/screenshots.html

  • Best file manager to exist on earth
  • Tabbed browsing
  • Viewer for common audio and video formats
  • Viewer for common documents
  • Complete archive support for RAR, 7Z and ZIP and some other common formats
  • Best ever Windows integration by any such program
  • Has burning and image making tools inbuilt
  • Has image editing tools inbuilt
  • Complex search feature
  • And any other little utilities you can imagine….

But it is highly disadvantageous. Reasons are:

  • No Linux or Mac support
  • Exorbitant price ($89 for all the things mentioned above)
  • Lite version available ($49) but crappier than MultiCommander, Double Commander and Unreal Commander (all three free!)

 

Worthy of mention

 

FreeCommander XE

  • Feature set is good
  • Tabbed browsing is better than others
  • Layout is awesome
  • Moderate resources consumption
  • Lacks support of content plugins, FTP client and file splitting features

 

CubicExplorer

  • Feature set is okay-ish
  • Looks are good
  • Bookmarks and quick-links access in side panel help save time at work
  • Tabbed browsing is better than others, and are almost double-sized (for the better!)
  • Lacks a lot of features like support of any TotalCommander plugins

 

Conclusion

 

MultiCommander is for system administrators.

SpeedCommander is made for power users like me who want to make the most out of time.

Those who want 4 panes, use Q-Dir.

Those concerned about Windows future and want to have a file manager with Linux or Mac support, go for Double Commander.

The choice is yours.

Advertisements

Need help on any technology matters? Email me at harshch@outlook.com

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Software
8 comments on “The best file manager
  1. Dayana Pears says:

    Nice article but in my opinion the best file manager is this one: http://www.winzip.com/win/en/learn/file-management.html but I am sure your tool works fine too

    • I find it hard to agree with your opinion. Nobody likes using ZIP format, and RAR or 7Z formats are preferred everywhere because of space and time saving plus lots of features compared to WinZip.

      WinZip era was long over, ma’am. This is 2017.

  2. BlackCarpet says:

    Hi Yo~
    How are you lol
    long time no chat
    Great review btw~
    Personally I used total commander for managing updates of files and it was a good experience.

  3. Maxx says:

    How about Total Commander?

    • SpeedCommander is better in every respect.

      The real strength of Total Commander lies in its addon system, which Double Commander (free) and Unreal Commander (free) have.

      Total Commander was one of the ones to master the File Manager software, but obviously nothing stands through the sands of time.

  4. random user says:

    nice review.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

harsh0chaudhary

harsh0chaudhary

Need help on any technology matters? Email me at harshch@outlook.com

View Full Profile →

Enter your email address to follow HC Tech Byte and receive email notifications.

Join 152 other followers

Old Tech Bytes
Tags
5x 6p 7-zip 7-zip 9.34 alpha 7Z 7zip 7zip 9.34 7zip 16.02 7zip alpha adobe Advanced System Care Android android 4.5 android 5 Android M android nokia Android Pay anti piracy antivirus Antiy AVL Any Video Converter for Mac app settings arch arch linux asus AV avast AVG Avira AVL B1 Free Archiver backup benchmark benchmark test BIOS Bitdefender BitDefender TrafficLight Bitdefender USB Immunizer BLAKE2 BlueTooth 4.2 bluray boost Boost by Reason bootable disc bootloader BootRacer brasero browser wars burnaware call feature card slot CCEnhancer CCleaner cdburnerxp cd burning centos chrome chrome 45 chromeos clonezilla CMOS comodo comodo firewall Comodo Internet Security compression tool coolpad CPU cubic explorer cubicexplorer daemon damn small linux data recovery data recovery software data recovery tool data usage DBAN dd backup debian defraggler directory opus disc burning DiskFresh document converter dopus double commander download accelerator plus download manager downthemall Doze drivers dvd burning easeus Emsisoft Online Armor eraser eRightSoft fedora FF Multi Converter file archiver file manager file managers fingerprint firefox firefox 40 firefox call FixWin flashget flashgot foxit foxspeed foxspeed ultimate framaroot FreeARC free commander freecommander freecommander xe free commander xe free download manager freemake Free MIDI to MP3 Converter gigaget GigaTweaker Glary Utilities gmail hera GnomeRAR Google google maps google now GPU honor 5x HTC huawei idm IE imgburn install windows internet download manager Internet Explorer iolo iphone iwork java k3b kali linux Kaspersky Keka kingsoft kingsoft office kmplayer km player le1s lenovo less internet data usage lg g5 libreoffice light linkextend Linux linux mint Live CD load Windows lollipop Mac malwarebytes memory card microsoft Microsoft doomsday microsoft office Microsoft self-destruct MIDI MIUI MIUI battery saver mobile security money moto mozilla ms office multi commander multicommander mxone mx one NAND lock NanoZip nero nero linux netscape Netscape Navigator nexus nightly ninja pendisk ninja pen disk No-frills CPU nokia nokia android Nokia X2 NoScript office office 365 office suite oneplus openoffice opensuse opera opera next p7zip Panda parted magic PC Decrapifier PeaZip photoscape picasa PIPA Piracy pirates PlayStore plugins Process Piglet Process Tamer protection puppy linux Q-Dir qbittorrent r-studio RAM RAR RAR5 RARMachine recuva red hat redhat redo abckup Reduce data usage Repair rescatux rhel rle ROM ROM Toolbox root rooting rstudio s7 s7 edge samsung SAR Screen size SD card SD card slot security sensors SetCPU slackware Slim Cleaner SlimCleaner smartphone SMPS Sony SOPA speedcommander speed commander speedfan speedup SqueezeChart stamina mode steamos stellar phoenix data recovery StuffIt stylus SUPER SuperOneClick superuser suse System Mechanic systemrescuecd system rescue cd System Restore tails TAR TCPOptimizer test testdisk ToolWiz torrent total video converter trinity rescue kit TuneUp Utilities TweakMe! ubcd ubuntu ultimate boot cd ultraiso universal extractor Unix unlimited storage Unlocker unlocking unreal commander Unrevoked USB type C utorrent VirusTotal vlc VPN web browser Web Of Trust WiFi Windows Windows 7 Windows 8 Windows 8.1 Windows 10 Windows 10 Technical preview Windows XP Windows XP shutdown winpatrol winrar WinRAR 5.10 winrar 5.11 winrar 5.31 Wondershare Video Converter WOT wps wps office XDM xiaomi xperia z5 xtreme download manager yu yuphoria zenfone 2 ZIP ZIPX zonealarm zorin os
%d bloggers like this: