The best file archiver for Windows, Unix/Linux, Mac and Android


Hello! Today I am gonna talk about my favourite category of software – file archivers. Yeah, I am gonna show you the favourites I have found over the course of 4 years of research and testing of every file archiver out there – dead projects or slowly developed, or in fact the ones frequently updated.
But let me tell you what a file archiver a.k.a. compression tool is. A file archiver is a tool designed to combine several files into one file, which is ideal for sharing through file sharing sites or as attachments. It is also used for making backups. It may also have the ability to adjust the files in a way so that they together become a compact file on storage media.
I want to thank SqueezeChart (http://www.squeezechart.com/SqueezeChart.pdf) for providing me the latest compression benchmarks (saved me a lot of time, though I also did a benchmark years back).
RAR is the king on Windows, TAR on Unix/Linux and SIT/SITX on Mac. The real problem is: what solution to come up with for each of the three major platforms/OSes? No one usually writes an article with all solutions bundled, rather they divide it into three articles to get more pageviews on their blog/website. I do as promised. So my followers and first-time visitors, the discussion is going to start now. After about 4 years of research (emphasising on that), I am going to present my results to you.
But before that, you should know three things:
I have written only about the best archivers under each OS category.
RAR format is second only to ZIP in terms of popularity. 7Z is third most popular.
And what were the factors on which I selected the best out of the best? Here they are (no priority):

  • Popularity
  • Stability
  • Format efficiency
  • Program update frequency
  • Speedy response (loading times, not compressing times!)
  • Easy to use
  • SFX ability
  • Recovery record ability
  • Security
  • Comment feature
  • Looks
  • Theme availability

 

best file archiver

So, the selected utilities are:

  • Windows: Universal Extractor, WinRAR, 7-Zip, FreeARC, PeaZip (not discussed)
  • Unix/Linux: GnomeRAR, WinRAR, p7zip, FreeARC, PeaZip (discussed here)
  • Mac: WinRAR, Keka, SimplyRAR, The Unarchiver, StuffIt
  • Android: RAR for Android 5.10, B1 Free Archiver

Note: StuffIt Deluxe is always a bad option since its decompression needs a special 10 MB StuffIt Expander tool to be downloaded. Hence not discussed and strictly not recommended by me.

Windows
 

Universal Extractor 1.6.1
It is basically the Unarchiver of Windows, just that it is much more powerful. It only extracts and not compresses, so can be a sidekick alongwith the main archive tool to be used. The list of formats it can extract is too long, hence see this link: http://legroom.net/software/uniextract#formats

WinRAR 5.11 beta 1 (SHAREWARE)
Looks, features and efficiency – it got all in 1.6 MBs. A list of all the features it has:
Most stable
Very efficient
Wizard mode for novices
Frequently updated
SFX ability (also installer creation ability)
Multivolume support
Very speedy response
Superb recovery record feature (also adjustable!)
Comment feature
Best security of all
Advanced BLAKE2 hash checksum (also old CRC hash)
Almost all common formats supported
Best looks
Themes available
Note: One feature it has which no archiver on any platform has: set profiles and add them into context menu with immediate execution (no dialog box popping up!).
It got one cons:
$30 for lifetime license (justified!)

7-Zip 9.34 alpha (FREE AND OPEN SOURCE)
Bad looks, less efficiency and even lesser features – that’s what it is. A list of all the features it got:
Free and open-source
Good security
Most speedy
Least efficient (nice compression though)
SFX ability
Multivolume support
3rd party themes available (7-Zip Theme Manager: http://www.7ztm.de)
It has lots of cons:
Unstable (stable till 9.20 version)
No wizard mode
No context menu additions by default (novices will have to Google for solutions)
An ancient-looking software
Very slow development

FreeARC 0.67 alpha (March 2014) (FREE AND OPEN SOURCE)
Very similar to WInRAR. I can see it being the open source variant of WinRAR. I also see it as RAR and 7Z combined to get a super hybrid format, and lots of efficiency. Just if its development and interface were better. A look at all its cons:
Equal to WinRAR minus: the good looks, speed response, efficiency, comprehensive installer creation ability, multivolume feature and wizard mode. Also no themes.

NanoZip 0.09 alpha (FREE)
The PAQ of the efficient archivers. Competes with the mathematically advanced RK and PAQ family formats while also competing with the efficient archivers. Provides magically compressed files. Just that it is not developed and is still in the alpha stage. A list of the features it has:
Magically efficient
Super speedy and clean interface
Super speedy compression
SFX ability
The cons:
Development at snail’s pace (3 years ago last release)
No wizard mode
No security
No comment feature
No GUI for SFXes
No context menu feature

Conclusion
WinRAR wins hands down. FreeARC at no. 2. 7-Zip at no. 3. NanoZip at no. 4.

 

Unix/Linux
You don’t have many good options for Unix/Linux systems. And since the formats used are comparatively less complicated (TAR), we have few options to select the best archiver.
WinRAR
It is only a command-line version, and most Linux users are aware of how to use command line apps, unlike Windows and Mac dumb people. For some who don’t like it, I have another alternative for you down.

GnomeRAR
It is basically WinRAR that has got a usable and nice interface for itself. Only for GNOME distro users.

I can’t disappoint KDE distro users, so I have a trick down my sleeves for you:
DoubleCommander with RAR command-line file  (trust me, it will work!)

PeaZip
This is the real winner here, with the best GUI/interface in Linux. A look at its features:
Ability to decompress over 130 formats without any support/addons
Compresses to TAR, ZIP, 7Z, GZIP, BZIP2 and the PAQ variants
Speedy and clean interface
SFX ability for 7Z and ZIP
Context menu integration
It has no cons as far as I know (atleast for Linux).

p7zip
As discussed above (see 7-Zip in Windows category), it is not that nice. Though since many options aren’t available, it is popular.

FreeARC
It again is not that good, and ARC format is not so popular on any platform.

Conclusion
PeaZip wins hands down. WinRAR at no. 2. 7-Zip at no. 3. FreeARC at no. 4.

 

Mac
There are even fewer options here, as listed above.
StuffIt
It has a very uncommon format SIT/SITX which is only used and seen on Macs. Please abandon it and use something more common like ZIP or 7Z format. Strictly not recommended.

WinRAR
A command-line version is available for Mac.

RARMachine
Same as WinRAR with a usable interface.

Keka
It is the 7-Zip of Mac. Powerful and has the ability to compress into 7Z, ZIP, TAR and some other uncommon formats. Nice.

Conclusion
Keka wins hands down. WinRAR/RARMachine at no. 2. StuffIt does not deserve any rank.

Android
RAR 5.10
It is the WinRAR of Android. As discussed above, its popularity and efficiency can’t be beaten till decades.

B1 Free Archiver
A cross-platform archiver, it has its own B1 format. Nice but you are lucky if you find one B1 file in your lifetime anywhere. It also offers ZIP support.

Conclusion
RAR wins hands down. B1 is the only other option. Rest are only fakes and extractors found on Play Store.

Final Conclusion

So what I can see is this: WinRAR (or RAR) is for all platforms and is second only to ZIP in terms of popularity. So use WinRAR. And just to assure you that my blog is not very popular (as of August 10, 2014) so I cannot be paid by WinRAR to write such a comprehensive cross-platform review.

Advertisements

Need help on any technology matters? Email me at harshch@outlook.com

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Software
5 comments on “The best file archiver for Windows, Unix/Linux, Mac and Android
  1. […] = ''; } Q-Dir – Make file/folder management to the summitThe best file archiver for Windows, Unix/Linux, Mac and Androidimg#wpstats{display:none} .recentcomments a{display:inline !important;padding:0 !important;margin:0 […]

  2. Delilah says:

    Hello! I’m at work surfing around your blog from my new apple iphone!
    Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts!
    Carry on the outstanding work!

  3. The best file archiver for Windows, Unix/Linux, Mac and Android | HC Tech Byte

  4. It’s nearly impossible to find well-informed people about this subject, but you seem like you know what you’re talking
    about! Thanks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

harsh0chaudhary

harsh0chaudhary

Need help on any technology matters? Email me at harshch@outlook.com

View Full Profile →

Enter your email address to follow HC Tech Byte and receive email notifications.

Join 152 other followers

Old Tech Bytes
Tags
5x 6p 7-zip 7-zip 9.34 alpha 7Z 7zip 7zip 9.34 7zip 16.02 7zip alpha adobe Advanced System Care Android android 4.5 android 5 Android M android nokia Android Pay anti piracy antivirus Antiy AVL Any Video Converter for Mac app settings arch arch linux asus AV avast AVG Avira AVL B1 Free Archiver backup benchmark benchmark test BIOS Bitdefender BitDefender TrafficLight Bitdefender USB Immunizer BLAKE2 BlueTooth 4.2 bluray boost Boost by Reason bootable disc bootloader BootRacer brasero browser wars burnaware call feature card slot CCEnhancer CCleaner cdburnerxp cd burning centos chrome chrome 45 chromeos clonezilla CMOS comodo comodo firewall Comodo Internet Security compression tool coolpad CPU cubic explorer cubicexplorer daemon damn small linux data recovery data recovery software data recovery tool data usage DBAN dd backup debian defraggler directory opus disc burning DiskFresh document converter dopus double commander download accelerator plus download manager downthemall Doze drivers dvd burning easeus Emsisoft Online Armor eraser eRightSoft fedora FF Multi Converter file archiver file manager file managers fingerprint firefox firefox 40 firefox call FixWin flashget flashgot foxit foxspeed foxspeed ultimate framaroot FreeARC free commander freecommander freecommander xe free commander xe free download manager freemake Free MIDI to MP3 Converter gigaget GigaTweaker Glary Utilities gmail hera GnomeRAR Google google maps google now GPU honor 5x HTC huawei idm IE imgburn install windows internet download manager Internet Explorer iolo iphone iwork java k3b kali linux Kaspersky Keka kingsoft kingsoft office kmplayer km player le1s lenovo less internet data usage lg g5 libreoffice light linkextend Linux linux mint Live CD load Windows lollipop Mac malwarebytes memory card microsoft Microsoft doomsday microsoft office Microsoft self-destruct MIDI MIUI MIUI battery saver mobile security money moto mozilla ms office multi commander multicommander mxone mx one NAND lock NanoZip nero nero linux netscape Netscape Navigator nexus nightly ninja pendisk ninja pen disk No-frills CPU nokia nokia android Nokia X2 NoScript office office 365 office suite oneplus openoffice opensuse opera opera next p7zip Panda parted magic PC Decrapifier PeaZip photoscape picasa PIPA Piracy pirates PlayStore plugins Process Piglet Process Tamer protection puppy linux Q-Dir qbittorrent r-studio RAM RAR RAR5 RARMachine recuva red hat redhat redo abckup Reduce data usage Repair rescatux rhel rle ROM ROM Toolbox root rooting rstudio s7 s7 edge samsung SAR Screen size SD card SD card slot security sensors SetCPU slackware Slim Cleaner SlimCleaner smartphone SMPS Sony SOPA speedcommander speed commander speedfan speedup SqueezeChart stamina mode steamos stellar phoenix data recovery StuffIt stylus SUPER SuperOneClick superuser suse System Mechanic systemrescuecd system rescue cd System Restore tails TAR TCPOptimizer test testdisk ToolWiz torrent total video converter trinity rescue kit TuneUp Utilities TweakMe! ubcd ubuntu ultimate boot cd ultraiso universal extractor Unix unlimited storage Unlocker unlocking unreal commander Unrevoked USB type C utorrent VirusTotal vlc VPN web browser Web Of Trust WiFi Windows Windows 7 Windows 8 Windows 8.1 Windows 10 Windows 10 Technical preview Windows XP Windows XP shutdown winpatrol winrar WinRAR 5.10 winrar 5.11 winrar 5.31 Wondershare Video Converter WOT wps wps office XDM xiaomi xperia z5 xtreme download manager yu yuphoria zenfone 2 ZIP ZIPX zonealarm zorin os
%d bloggers like this: